Made from scratch with real butter, our Signature Cupcake is 2 to 3 bites; bigger than a “mini” but not quite a “regular." We’ve been told they’re “just the right size!” 

$10.99 4-Pack 

$15.99 6-Pack 

$29.99 Dozen   

$58.99 2 Dozen



Pickup as early as 10AM the next day!   

Pre-orders help us balance our baking & waste and this is our way of saying Thanks! 

Mix & Match any quantities/flavor when you pre-order + select your pick-up date.
(Tuesday - Saturday only)


Limited quantities available daily for walk-ins.  Ordering ahead helps us make sure you get just what you need.

Orders placed before 4 PM will be available for pick-up at 10 AM the next business day. For same-day orders, please call the shop at 573-356-0867 to check availability before placing your online order.

Current shop hours are Tuesday thru Friday 10-6,  Saturday 10-4.

Simply Vanilla

Fluffy vanilla buttercream piled on our house-made vanilla cake, featuring real butter and vanilla topped with a white chocolate feather.

Simply Chocolate

Made-from-scratch chocolate cake with a big ole' dollop of our chocolate buttercream and mini Hershey® bar.

Simply Strawberry

Strawberry buttercream piped on top of strawberry cake with sprinkles and strawberry gummy bear.

German Chocolate

Gooey coconut pecan icing on top of our made-from-scratch dark chocolate cake.

Chocolate Peanut Butter

Peanut butter buttercream on top of our house-made chocolate cake finished off with chocolate sprinkles and a mini Reese's® cup.

Salted Caramel Pretzel

Our house-made vanilla cake topped with vanilla buttercream and drizzled with salted caramel and a pretzel.

Cherry Almond

We fold cherries into our almond cake batter and top it off with fluffy cherry buttercream, almonds and a cherry on top.

Dark Chocolate Raspberry

Made-from-scratch dark chocolate cake piled high with raspberry buttercream and fresh raspberry.